Comments back from one of the referees for a paper I submitted to a big and very well respected journal for the field I work in:
This paper presents a pixel-swapping algorithm to mapping rural land cover objects from fine spatial resolution images. It is a well organized and written paper. The research method is certainly innovative and the results are interpolated clearly. Overall this is a good piece of research work. Everything in the manuscript is perfect. I do not see any revision necessary.
I couldn’t agree more.